Refinancing vs. Home Equity Loan: Which One Is Right for You?

 


Need cash from your home? Two popular options—refinancing and home equity loans—can unlock thousands, but they work very differently. Choosing the right one can save you money, lower your interest rate, or help you fund home improvements, education, or debt consolidation.

This guide breaks down refinancing vs. home equity loans in simple terms. We’ll cover how each works, their pros and cons, and how to decide which best fits your situation.

What Is a Refinance?

Refinancing replaces your existing mortgage with a new one, ideally with better terms—like a lower interest rate, a shorter term, or cash back.

There are two main types of refinance:

  • Rate-and-term refinance: Change the loan’s interest rate, term, or both

  • Cash-out refinance: Borrow more than you owe and take the difference in cash

💡 Example: If you owe $180,000 on a $300,000 home, you might refinance for $220,000 and take $40,000 in cash.

✅ Pro Tip: A lower interest rate through refinancing can save you tens of thousands over the life of your loan.

What Is a Home Equity Loan?

A home equity loan is a second loan you take out against the value of your home. You keep your original mortgage, and the new loan is based on your equity.

  • Paid out as a lump sum

  • Fixed interest rate and term

  • You make two monthly payments: one for your mortgage and one for your home equity loan

💡 Example: You owe $180,000 on a $300,000 home. You borrow $40,000 as a home equity loan. Now you have two loans secured by your home.

Refinancing vs. Home Equity Loan: What’s the Difference?

FeatureRefinanceHome Equity Loan
Replaces your mortgageYesNo
Adds second loanNoYes
Interest RateUsually lower (esp. for primary loan)Typically higher than mortgage
Monthly PaymentsOneTwo (mortgage + equity loan)
Lump Sum CashOnly with cash-out refinanceYes
Fixed Rates AvailableYesYes
Closing CostsHigher (2–5% of loan)Lower (often 1–2%)
Use of FundsFlexibleFlexible

✅ Pro Tip: If you have a low mortgage rate already, a home equity loan may be better to avoid losing that rate.

When to Choose a Refinance

Refinancing may be the better choice when:

1. Interest Rates Have Dropped

If today’s rates are lower than your current mortgage, refinancing can reduce your monthly payment or let you pay off your loan faster.

🧮 Example: Refinancing a $250,000 loan from 7.5% to 6.0% can lower your payment by $225/month.

2. You Want to Consolidate High-Interest Debt

A cash-out refinance lets you pay off credit cards, personal loans, or student loans with your mortgage at a lower rate.

3. You Plan to Stay in the Home Long-Term

Since refinancing comes with closing costs, you’ll need time to recoup those expenses through monthly savings.

✅ Stat: Most homeowners break even on refinance costs after 2–3 years of lower payments.

4. You Want to Change Loan Terms

You can:

  • Switch from an adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) to fixed-rate

  • Reduce a 30-year mortgage to a 15-year loan

  • Refinance from FHA to conventional to remove mortgage insurance

When to Choose a Home Equity Loan

A home equity loan may be the better option when:

1. You Need a Lump Sum

Perfect for large one-time expenses like:

  • Home renovations

  • Tuition

  • Medical bills

  • Starting a small business

2. You Have a Low Mortgage Rate You Want to Keep

A home equity loan doesn’t touch your first mortgage, so you keep your existing low interest rate.

3. You Don’t Want High Upfront Costs

Home equity loans typically have lower closing costs than refinances, sometimes under $1,000.

4. You Have a Short-Term Cash Need

These loans work well if you plan to pay off the loan quickly and want a fixed, predictable payment.

✅ Pro Tip: If you only need ongoing access to funds (like for staged renovations), consider a HELOC (Home Equity Line of Credit) instead.

Costs to Consider

Refinancing Costs:

  • Appraisal: $300–$500

  • Application fees

  • Title insurance

  • Attorney fees (in some states)

  • Total: 2%–5% of the loan amount

Home Equity Loan Costs:

  • Lower overall

  • May include origination and closing fees

  • Some lenders offer no-closing-cost loans

✅ Pro Tip: Always compare loan offers from multiple lenders using a mortgage marketplace or affiliate tool here.

Risks of Both Options

RiskRefinancingHome Equity Loan
Taps home equity✅ Yes✅ Yes
Risk of foreclosure✅ Yes✅ Yes
Affects credit score✅ Hard credit check + new loan✅ Hard credit check + new loan
Possible fees✅ Higher✅ Lower

❗ Caution: Borrowing against your home increases risk if you lose income or can't make payments.

Example Scenario: Refinancing vs. Home Equity Loan

Let’s say you need $40,000 to renovate your kitchen and bathrooms.

Option 1: Cash-Out Refinance

  • Refinance $180,000 balance into $220,000 loan at 6%

  • New payment: ~$1,320/month

  • Total new loan = one, streamlined payment

  • Higher closing costs

Option 2: Home Equity Loan

  • Keep $180,000 mortgage at 5.5%

  • Add $40,000 home equity loan at 8%

  • Equity loan payment: ~$400/month

  • Total monthly payments: ~$1,200 (mortgage) + $400 (equity) = $1,600

  • Lower upfront costs, but two payments

✅ Verdict: Refinance if you get a better rate overall. Choose home equity loan if rates are rising and you want to keep your current mortgage.

Refinance vs. Home Equity Loan in Kenya (or African Markets)

In many African markets, mortgage refinance is rare, but home equity loans or asset-backed lending is growing.

Kenya Example:

  • Equity Bank, KCB, and Absa offer home equity products

  • Often called mortgage top-ups

  • Interest rates may be fixed or variable, often above 12%

  • Appraisal and legal fees apply

✅ Pro Tip (Kenya): Always ask for total cost of credit (TCC) and compare across banks. The Central Bank of Kenya’s portal helps with this.

Should You Use Equity to Invest?

Some homeowners use equity to:

  • Invest in rental property

  • Buy land

  • Start a business

⚠️ Caution: If your investment fails, you still owe the debt—and risk losing your home.

✅ Advice: Only borrow against your home for investments if you have a solid business plan, emergency fund, and low risk tolerance.

FAQs

❓ Will refinancing hurt my credit?

A hard inquiry will cause a small dip, but your score typically recovers within a few months.

❓ Can I refinance or get a home equity loan with bad credit?

It’s possible, but you’ll face higher interest rates and fewer lender options.

❓ How much equity do I need?

Most lenders require:

  • 20% equity for cash-out refinancing

  • 15%–20% equity for home equity loans

Final Thoughts: Use Equity Wisely

Your home is likely your biggest asset. Whether you refinance or take a home equity loan, the goal is to use that equity to improve your financial future—not jeopardize it.

Ask yourself:

  • What’s my goal?

  • What are the long-term costs?

  • Am I improving my net worth?

So—which is better for your financial goals: refinancing your mortgage or tapping into your equity with a second loan?

Start by comparing rates and terms from trusted lenders to find the best fit.

Comments

Post a Comment